Energy Landscape

  • Jensen Maritime Consultants – leveraging a unique porthole on the maritime industry – anticipates and meets demand in the burgeoning maritime LNG sectors. Nevertheless, says Jensen’s Johan Sperling, it’s not rocket science. 

    At the recent Passenger Vessel Association (PVA) annual meeting held in Houston, Texas, Jensen Maritime Consultants had on display just a couple of their many design efforts underway at the Crowley-owned design and engineering shop. Naturally, those designs had the use or carriage of LNG as their central theme. LNG, at least on this side of the pond, is still largely uncharted waters, but that’s hardly the case for Jensen. Already at the heart of many new initiatives, it is clear that Jensen will never be far from the LNG epicenter when it finally takes off here in North America.

    Early Engagement – Unique Perspective
    Although owned by Crowley, Jensen’s client base is wide and includes all sizes and types of tonnage. That said; Jensen Maritime Vice President Johan Sperling says that his firm has a unique view on the industry that, perhaps, some competitors do not. That window potentially provides a sharper look at what could come next. Nevertheless, he says, business is business. “We have NDAs with all of our clients. We have a half dozen, each with somewhat different designs, including Crowley. I’m sure you can imagine that everyone wants to be first, but at the same time do not want to tip off the competitors to what they are doing. At Jensen – and a lot of people don’t realize this – 80 percent of our business is not Crowley-related. So we have strict firewalls in place and we’re very good at keeping promises to others about what we are doing.”
    Ongoing in-house projects include the LNG bunker barge, the LNG-powered tug, LNG powered ATB designs and of course, the design work with the larger, faster and environmentally-friendly liquefied natural gas (LNG)-powered, combination container – Roll-On/Roll-Off (ConRo) ships. Already in the thick of LNG, Jensen will provide construction management and supervision in the shipyard throughout the building phase of the ConRo’s.
    In terms of Jensen’s LNG tug design, the preliminary work was, to a certain extent, a leap of faith on the part of Jensen. Sperling says, “We have contracts for clients, but we started before we had those contracts and went out on a limb ourselves and decided to design something that would attract those clients.”
    The LNG bunker barge was a different story because the maritime industry needs infrastructure to move LNG. Sperling explains, “Harvey Gulf, Tote, Crowley, and Matson have decided to spend a lot of money to build large vessels that will burn LNG and gas. They have to get the gas to the vessels. Meanwhile, there are very few groups are willing to take the risk to help with the ‘chicken and egg’ question.”
    Sperling and Jensen nevertheless remain pragmatic. “First of all, it’s not rocket science. We’re not overly worried about the technology itself and I don’t think that anyone else is, either. LNG has been around a long time. Vessels don’t burn LNG, they burn gas. And when it changes to gas, it expands, which can present a problem. You basically take LNG and vaporize it, then it’s virtually the same system as compressed natural gas for over-the-road buses, dump trucks, etc. The safety record is very, very good. But, that said, if you spill LNG, all kinds of things can happen. LNG is cryogenic fluid, is extremely cold and causes myriad of considerations.  So we design to meet those challenges.  From our standpoint these are the most challenging areas. The good news is that this has been done for a long time and it has been long documented and we have in-house LNG experience here at Jensen.”

    Defining the Ideal Bunker Barge
    Jensen’s bunker barge designs are a closely guarded secret, but Sperling said that Jensen would focus on two basic sizes – ranging from capacities of 2000 to 3000 cubic meters. He added, “If you look at all the carriers that are contemplating or have committed to building LNG tonnage, all of the schedules are different. Some want to top off weekly, for example. Our designs satisfy most of the demands of what a big ship operator could want. The bunker barge has to be large enough to where it makes sense, but also small enough that it is affordable and economical. Others may be building bigger, some smaller. We’ve defined our range.”

    Sticker Shock
    According to Sperling, the first bunker barge has to be built as economically as is possible. That’s because the first mover in the market will have a limited customer base, at least to start with. He insists, “If it’s too expensive, you’ll have to charge too much for bunkers,” adding, “Once you talk about LNG equipment, the sticker shock is tremendous. In our case, we’re looking at simple cryogenic tanks – cylindrical in construction typically – that is proven technology. That’s the easiest way to get regulatory approvals. And, even though it is new for marine applications, you can point somewhere and say that it works. We’ll incorporate this into our bunker barge designs.”
    Jensen’s philosophy is that there is enough risk in these new ventures without introducing unknown variables. Sperling told MarineNews in February, “The Rule of thumb today: LNG equipment is about double the price of non-LNG components. We’re talking about the equipment. Whoever moves first takes the most risk because they are going to spend a lot of money and then the prices are going to drop. You don’t want to be first and get it wrong. This has certainly changed but the exponential cost jump is still there for LNG equipment.”

    Risk – and Reward
    In the beginning, Jensen went forward with its LNG pioneering efforts for several reasons. Sperling says, “It was a big risk – for a naval architect, time is money and we spent a lot of R&D time on this. In this case, we felt the risk was low enough because we think it’s real enough that someone will eventually pay for it and that’s exactly what has happened.”
    Jensen’s LNG design for tugboats got started in 2008. Since then, a lot of water has gone under the proverbial bridge. Sperling adds, “The engine manufacturers are just now ready to do something. And, as you can see, the first LNG tug has just been delivered out of a shipyard in Turkey for service in Norway oil fields. As you’ve probably seen in all those drawings – the LNG tanks were right underneath the house and accommodations. In the U.S. today, for safety reasons, we are designing vessels that put the LNG tanks somewhere else that is not in the same vertical zone as the accommodations. We have some constraints here that make it trickier for us and U.S. operators in general.”

    Design Aspects: uncharted waters
    As design professionals move forward on the domestic LNG front, they are finding that there are a lot of rules relating to containment that are both published and unpublished. Sperling says in regard to the process, “As of today, there’s nothing official that really ties us down. We need to do various things, and yes, we’ll get the approvals. It’s a special case approval situation. Both DNV and ABS are going to have to work with the Coast Guard. And, we will need to work with them, too. All of us – and the operators, including Crowley – are leading the charge to define what needs to be done, and that comes with a lot of responsibility. So, it’s important that we do everything possible, from the outset.”
     
    Tug Propulsion: Dual Fuel or LNG?
    Jensen’s tug designs are all pure LNG models. Sperling says there are very good reasons for that. “All of our harbor tug designs are gas only. That’s because we know we’ll have readily available fuel and the size of the engines currently available are appropriate to that size vessel. As it stands now, with the rules and guidelines we’ve been given, we can’t put large tanks aboard a tugboat without making the tugboat twice as big the others. If that’s the case, the capital cost of the tugboat makes is uneconomical in comparison to conventional.”
    Based on Jensen’s popular valor class design, their hardworking vessel will feature a 14-day endurance capability for harbor and escort work and will likely be outfitted with an innovative LNG package, including two Rolls Royce model US 255 Z-drives, driven by a pair of Bergen C26:33L6P gas engines. The storage tank will also be supplied by Rolls Royce (via Cryomar) and the vessel will be fitted with a hawser winch forward and a capstan aft for line handling. 

    Head of the Class: who is it?
    Jensen’s Sperling hedged a little when it came to declaring who would be chosen to provide class on its designs. Although deep in the heart of ABS country, it is also true that DNV has more LNG experience abroad. Because of that, he added, “ABS is doing a great job of catching up and they are doing their very best to make sure that they get to keep the market for small tugs, bunker barges and similar tonnages. I can’t tell you for sure that our designs or those of others are going to wind up being ABS. Right now, it’s a race between the two of them. In most things, whoever is first stands a good chance of being the experts or they could be the goat. In this case, DNV is riding that North Sea wave that they helped pioneer.”

    Performance: Does LNG stack up to Diesel?
    Jensen’s position on LNG tugs is that they have to make them equivalent or better to what’s out there now. Sperling insists, “Otherwise, people will question it and it is not going to happen. So, the goal is to be better. If you currently have a 40-ton bollard-pull tug, you aren’t going to replace it with a 35-ton bollard-pull LNG tug. That’s simply not going to be acceptable to industry. LNG units will have to have the same or better: in terms of horsepower, bollard pull, response time – everything.”

    SITREP LNG: cutting steel?
    Sperling is bullish on LNG in 2014, saying ““I wouldn’t be surprised if there is a keel laid in 2014. The reason is – and let’s just take Crowley as an example, since they are a client of Jensen – if there are LNG ships being built, when they are delivered, we better have something in the water that can serve them. In order to do that, we’re going to have to cut steel or order LNG equipment pretty soon. That involves the bunkering for those two ships. For the tugs, that’s a little different. There isn’t a particular need that they have to immediately go serve – it’s more about what risk do the owners want to take? People want to be first in this arena here, but they also don’t want to be first and then lose. My gut feeling is that something is going to happen this year.”

    Wild Cards
    As the LNG arena unfolds in North America, the variables are many, the certainties few and the competition remains exciting. For that reason alone, the advent of non-traditional players in the infrastructure and bunker side of the business is very real.
    Sperling explains, “This is a game between LNG users and LNG providers. And you know that some people have stuck their nose out and at some point are going to have to make sure that there is infrastructure – whether that’s Harvey Gulf, Tote, Crowley, Matson – whoever you pick out there. They need the oil companies to provide them with LNG and they also need someone to move the LNG from the pipeline to the vessel. So there’s a question between the owners and the oil companies of who is going to fund what. We’re very close to having to make decisions.”
    LNG itself has an enviable track record in terms of safety, environmental performance and delivering in the workboat arena. No wonder it has arrived on the scene in North America. For Jensen’s Johan Sperling, it is an exciting time as new concepts are brought forward. The same holds true of the Coast Guard and the classification societies. Sperling adds, “Typically, when something new is proposed to the Coast Guard and even the class societies, they can often be critical of the idea, due to the increased risk. But, in the case of LNG, they are open to new ideas that make sense. And for industry, that’s very exciting. And for us engineers and designers, we get to put on our thinking caps and solve problems.”
    The LNG arena is new, exciting and bursting with great potential to transform the transportation and energy landscape forever here in North America. LNG is here to stay. A lot of work remains to be done. That said; it’s also not rocket science.



    (As published in the March 2014 edition of Marine News - www.marinelink.com)

     

  • MR Feb-24#40  and now, making 
you consider energy density, you need about)
    February 2024 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 40

    also have our ? eet nia than HFO,” said Brindley. “That’s just the weight. When engineering team, which looks at the here and now, making you consider energy density, you need about three times the sure the vessels are as ef? cient as possible. We need to catch quantity of ammonia for an equivalent energy

  • MR Feb-24#39  location, 
In July 2023, MAN Energy Solutions announced the)
    February 2024 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 39

    to traditional diesel fuel],” said major progress expected in 2024. Räsänen. “You need to be careful on the bunkering location, In July 2023, MAN Energy Solutions announced the successful the size of the bunkering, how you pull your pipes between ? rst running of a test engine [MAN B&W two-stroke

  • MR Feb-24#38  be produced using renewable energy sources,   for a pilot)
    February 2024 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 38

    treatment. • Renewable Production Potential: “Green” Ammonia While ammonia itself is without carbon, there is the need can be produced using renewable energy sources, for a pilot fuel to start the combustion process. “The engine such as wind or solar power, through electrolysis. manufacturers are looking

  • MR Feb-24#37 , at Yaskawa Environmental Energy / The Switch
The Switch’s)
    February 2024 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 37

    improves ef? ciency by 2-4% compared to synchronous machines." – Dr. Jussi Puranen, Head of Product Line, Electric Machines, at Yaskawa Environmental Energy / The Switch The Switch’s shaft generators start from <1MW and range up to 12MW+. Source: Wärtsilä Source: Aasen Shipping Source: The Switch www

  • MR Feb-24#36  PTO powertrain 
Source: MAN Energy Solutions
how the system)
    February 2024 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 36

    HYBRID 2-stroke controllable pitch propeller PTO powertrain Source: MAN Energy Solutions how the system is intended to operate, says Oskar Levander, VP Strategy & Business Development, Kongsberg Maritime. For example, a primary shaft-driven PTO rotates whenever the engine is running; a secondary one

  • MR Feb-24#35  50 tons of equip- lowers their energy consumption and to the)
    February 2024 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 35

    a shaft generator is not an insigni? - the ef? ciency of modern permanent magnet technology that cant undertaking. Around 50 tons of equip- lowers their energy consumption and to the variable speed ment needs to be installed into the engineroom drives that enable them to provide constant power over a wid- through

  • MR Feb-24#34  on the Rise
Source: MAN Energy Solutions
MR #2 (34-44))
    February 2024 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 34

    HYBRID Shaft Generators Demand on the Rise Source: MAN Energy Solutions MR #2 (34-44).indd 34 2/6/2024 8:47:46 AM

  • MR Feb-24#29  of changing  ing and enacting energy transition to hit  Also)
    February 2024 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 29

    . But with the Covid es facing any shipowner today: embrac- that’s just one potential talking point. pandemic and the myriad of changing ing and enacting energy transition to hit Also, there are around 16 different fuel cost dynamics, from raging in? ation to decarbonization targets. options for ships today

  • MR Feb-24#22  
of decarbonization, energy transition and autonomy)
    February 2024 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 22

    R&D MATT HART Matt Hart, Manager & Platform Leader, Marine & Stationary Power Systems, Wabtec, offers insights on how the megatrends of decarbonization, energy transition and autonomy all inspire Image courtesy Wabtec and impact the marine power solutions from Wabtec. By Greg Trauthwein Matt, to start us

  • MR Feb-24#20  of low and zero emission energy carriers, 
In all, 18)
    February 2024 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 20

    MARKETS FPSO technology dominates the region’s FPS demand. duction and storage of low and zero emission energy carriers, In all, 18 countries in West and East Africa are expected such as methanol and ammonia. One exciting development to receive new FPSOs, FLNGs and FPUs between 2024 and leverages

  • MR Feb-24#16  to prevent corrosion. 
lent energy as HFO.  The SPS sandwich)
    February 2024 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 16

    also creates oxygen-free condi- ton, it takes 2.4 times more methanol to generate the equiva- tions behind the steel plates to prevent corrosion. lent energy as HFO. The SPS sandwich panel system can be used in lieu of coffer- Conventionally, tanks storing low ? ashpoint fuels on board dams on all tank

  • MR Feb-24#13  times, the pandemic and the energy 
crisis, are behind them)
    February 2024 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 13

    21% falling one spot from the 2023 rankings. While companies may be con? dent that the worst of two key disruptors of recent times, the pandemic and the energy crisis, are behind them. Business disruption remains a key concern as ? rms are challenged to build resilience and diver- sify supply chains in

  • MR Feb-24#12  accel-
erate its adoption of energy-ef?  cient 
technologies)
    February 2024 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 12

    of these batteries has been least 40% by 2030, and 70% by 2050. The IMO’s target is ambitious, and the industry will need to accel- erate its adoption of energy-ef? cient technologies and fuels, such as wind propulsion, biofuels, hydrogen, and ammonia to meet its goal. Political Risks Political risks and

  • MR Feb-24#6  of maritime transport as both  Energy transition and alternative)
    February 2024 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 6

    to increase globally, and energies take a bite out of the bottom line. Editor - MarineNews Eric Haun the importance of maritime transport as both Energy transition and alternative fuels are [email protected] a global commerce enabler and a bedrock of everywhere. While traditional diesel is still

  • MR Feb-24#4  Learning Systems, maker of  energy and maritime sectors.)
    February 2024 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 4

    van Hemmen is the President Murray Goldberg is CEO of Ma- gic planning experience in the of Martin & Ottaway, a marine rine Learning Systems, maker of energy and maritime sectors. consulting ? rm that specializes in MarineLMS. the resolution of technical, opera- MacLeod tional and ? nancial issues. Business

  • MR Feb-24#2  of decar-
bonization, energy transition and autonomy)
    February 2024 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 2

    Courtesy ARC 22 Marine Power: The Future is Now Departments Matt Hart, Wabtec Corporation, offers insights on how the megatrends of decar- bonization, energy transition and autonomy drive engine innovations. 4 Authors & Contributors By Greg Trauthwein 6 Editorial 8 Training Tips for Ships Addressing Barriers 26

  • MN Feb-24#38  operate  6.2 MWh Orca battery energy storage system from Corvus)
    February 2024 - Marine News page: 38

    of Crowley’s mi- grated electrical propulsion package provided by ABB, a crogrid shoreside charging station. The vessel will operate 6.2 MWh Orca battery energy storage system from Corvus with zero emissions while providing the complete perfor- Energy and two electrically driven Schottel RudderPropel- mance

  • MN Feb-24#29  been experienced in other energy industries, such as 
coal)
    February 2024 - Marine News page: 29

    .” In terms of cost escalations and other “bumps in the road” for offshore wind, Møller pointed to similar challenges that have been experienced in other energy industries, such as coal and nuclear power. “And if we go back to before the COVID crisis at least, then [offshore wind was] compatible or have

  • MN Feb-24#28  wind still blows “free”, but  energy future. While a handful)
    February 2024 - Marine News page: 28

    have placed an exclamation point on wind is incorporated as a growing part of the United States’ the word “wild”. Yes, the wind still blows “free”, but energy future. While a handful of projects have been de- mounting challenges have proven that harnessing its railed, others continue to push forward with

  • MN Feb-24#20  workforce. 
the New York State Energy Research and Development)
    February 2024 - Marine News page: 20

    a cascading impact on nouncing on January 3 that they had reached terms with the U.S. maritime industry and the American workforce. the New York State Energy Research and Development For example, concurrent with the termination of the Em- Authority (NYSERDA) to terminate the Offshore Wind pire Wind 2 OREC

  • MN Feb-24#17   connection of battery energy storage  modate increase)
    February 2024 - Marine News page: 17

    Emergency Transportation can be mitigated through the inter- sels and upgrade terminals to accom- Authority (WETA) for upgrading connection of battery energy storage modate increase power requirements. its ferry ? oats to include battery en- systems, but there are other signi? cant However, many operators

  • MN Feb-24#16  the Green
By Kaiya Levine, Energy & Sustainability Consultant)
    February 2024 - Marine News page: 16

    Column Going Green For Ferries to Go Green, Governments Will Need to Provide the Green By Kaiya Levine, Energy & Sustainability Consultant, Arup Whether it is from international organizations ? ve nautical miles or less, meaning they have relatively low or state government agencies, there is growing

  • MN Feb-24#11 Insights
All images: MITAGS
she explained. “We can have)
    February 2024 - Marine News page: 11

    Insights All images: MITAGS she explained. “We can have over 150 years of sea service sitting at the lunch table at any point in time, and it really creates an interesting and dynamic environment,” Gianel- loni said, referring to the instructional staff. “We are not in any way a certi? cate farm. The

  • MN Feb-24#6  writer specializing in marine, energy and envi- is a retired)
    February 2024 - Marine News page: 6

    February 2024 • Volume 35 Number 2 Contributors 3 1 24 6 5 7 8 1 Tom Ewing 5 Edward Lundquist is a freelance writer specializing in marine, energy and envi- is a retired naval of? cer who writes on maritime and ronmental issues. He contributes regularly to this magazine. security issues. He is