Isa Difference

  • P3: An alternative to tolls or lockage fees in public-private partnerships for inland waterways. 

     
    Within the generally sorry state of the U.S. inland waterways infrastructure, there are some locations where conditions are particularly dire. Among those in this latter situation are several locks and dams on the Illinois River, including the La Grange Lock and Dam and the Peoria Lock and Dam, both of which were completed in 1939. Both of them are on the U.S. National Register of Historic Places, which is a dubious distinction for a major transportation facility of the twenty-first century.
     
    The farmers in Illinois provide a significant portion of our nation’s corn and soybean crops, and the Illinois River plays an important role in getting those crops from the farms in Illinois to the Mississippi River and thence to New Orleans for export. It would be a major hardship for many corn and soybean growers in Illinois if either of the La Grange or Peoria lock and dam facilities were to become inoperable. However, there remain many competing needs for new construction, rehabilitations and major repairs throughout the inland waterways system, and the funding provided by Congress never addresses more than a small fraction of these needs.
     
    Corn and soybean growers in Illinois are understandably worried, therefore, that one or both of the La Grange or Peoria lock and dam facilities might fail before the necessary money is found to keep that from happening. Reflecting this concern, two organizations representing these constituencies—the Illinois Corn Growers Association (ICGA) and the Illinois Soybean Association (ISA)—have recently conducted extensive studies and proposed alternative solutions to fund the refurbishment or replacement of these locks and dams. Both organizations gave detailed presentations of similar solutions at the 12th Annual Waterways Symposium in New Orleans in November 2015.
     
    Public/Private Partnerships
    Both organizations propose using public-private partnerships in which some of the funding would be provided by private parties in some combination of debt and equity. As has been previously recognized with other public-private partnership proposals, such a structure needs to include a revenue source to provide economic return to the private party lender or equity investor. Both the ICGA and the ISA proposals include payments in the nature of fees or charges to be paid based on usage of the locks in order to generate this revenue.
     
    By and large, the inland waterways industry has opposed having such lock usage fees, by whatever name they might be called, as an element of any proposed public-private partnership for funding improvements to the inland waterways infrastructure. In April of this year, for example, Waterways Council, Inc. submitted letters to the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee and the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee signed by 75 organizations, including carriers, shippers, port authorities, labor unions, and trade associations (including several agricultural industry groups), opposing the imposition of tolls or lockage fees on inland waterways transportation. This opposition is repeatedly voiced by representatives of the inland waterways industry at conferences and in publications whenever any suggestion of such tolls or lockage fees arises.
     
    Those who propose tolls or lockage fees typically emphasize that what they are proposing this is just one suggestion and that other ideas are welcome if they will address the undisputed and urgent needs at hand. To help the inland waterways industry avoid being perceived as only naysayers who oppose tolls and lockage fees but who do not offer constructive alternatives, I wish to present—or perhaps it might be more accurately said, to recall—a public-private partnership approach that largely follows what has been recently suggested by ICGA and ISA, but without the tolls or lockage fees component.
     
    The models of debt and equity financing that have been suggested by ICGA and ISA recall those that were proposed in studies done in 2013 by the Texas Transportation Institute for the United Soybean Board and by the Horinko Group for the U.S. Soybean Export Council, but with this difference: the 2013 studies included proposals to use some portion of the fuel tax revenues that are paid into the Inland Waterways Trust Fund to provide the necessary debt service and return on equity for such financing.
     
    Sorting out the Funding Rules
    The use of funds received by the Inland Waterways Trust Fund to support the issuance of bonds is also contemplated by Section 2004 of the Water Resources Reform and Development Act of 2014 (WRRDA 2014). That section of the statute requires the Army Corps of Engineers to study “potential benefits and implications of authorizing the issuance of federally tax-exempt bonds secured against the available proceeds, including project annual receipts, in the Inland Waterways Trust Fund.” By a memorandum dated June 28, 2016, the Corps issued “implementation guidance” which was simply a report that the study has not yet been started since no funds have yet been specifically appropriated for it.
     
    In the model presented by ISA at the Waterways Symposium in November 2015, annual revenues of approximately $11 million were projected to support a total of approximately $150 million of combined debt and equity financing. The ISA model also assumed that there would be contributions from the Federal government and other sources totaling approximately $405 million, for a total of approximately $555 million, which could be applied to address the needs of several lock and dam installations on the Illinois River in addition to those of La Grange and Peoria. The ISA model assumed a financing term of 30 years, bond proceeds (i.e., debt) in the amount of $128 million in two tiers with interest rates of 3.5 percent and 4.75 percent, respectively, and an annual return of 11 percent on an equity investment of $22 million.
     
    A Twist on the Plan
    A variation on this theme that should be considered would be the issuance of the same amount of total financing, i.e., $150 million, but comprised entirely of bonds or other forms of debt. According to the presentation by ISA, this amount should be sufficient to address the needs of at least the La Grange Lock and Dam and the Peoria Lock and Dam. Assuming that this bond financing would have the same term as in the ISA model, i.e., 30 years, and that the same amount of annual revenue, $11 million, would be available from the Inland Waterways Trust Fund for the payment of interest and principal on these bonds, this would translate into an effective interest rate of 6 percent on the bonds, which would be attractive in today’s interest rate environment.
     
    The ISA model assumed an interest rate of only 4.75 percent on the portion of the bonds with a Standard and Poor’s rating of BBB, generally considered the lowest rating that qualifies as investment grade. Even further, if those bonds were tax-exempt, a possibility contemplated by Section 2004 of WRRDA 2014, then such an interest rate would represent an even higher effective return to the holder of such bonds. On the other hand, if the interest rate on the bonds turned out to be less than 6 percent, then either a greater amount of financing could be raised for the same $11 million of annual debt service, or the required annual debt service on $150 million of bond proceeds would be less, or the length of the financing term could be shortened. Anyone who has refinanced a home mortgage to take advantage of declining interest rates knows how these factors relate to each other.
     
    To be sure, committing a certain amount from the Inland Waterways Trust Fund to support a long-term bond financing would make those funds unavailable for any other infrastructure projects during the term of that financing. However, the ISA and ICGA models, the studies for the United Soybean Board and the U.S. Soybean Export Council, other proposals for public-private partnerships, and the Corps of Engineers itself all recognize the cost savings and other advantages that come from borrowing against a future revenue stream to obtain full funding of a project up-front, rather than paying for it piecemeal. To return to the home mortgage illustration, no one buys a home one room at a time, year by year, as each year’s current income allows.
     
    In a letter to Congress earlier this year, the Inland Waterways Users Board reported that, for the 10-year period 2005–2014, each penny of the fuel tax paid by carriers on the inland waterways generated $4 million each year for the Inland Waterways Trust Fund. This means that, in effect, less than three cents of the current 29-cents per gallon fuel tax would need to be allocated to supporting a bond financing of $150 million.
     
    This alternative proposal would require some legislative changes in order for it to be implemented, but so also would the imposition of some form of toll or lockage fee. Each Water Resources Development Act that is passed by Congress provides an opportunity to enact such changes, as most recently evidenced by the important steps taken in WRRDA 2014. There is currently pending in Congress a bill that will hopefully become the Water Resources Development Act of 2016, and efforts are being made to have such enactments restored to a biennial schedule. Each of them will provide an opportunity to find a way to use public-private partnerships to provide funding to restore and improve the inland waterways infrastructure. In this article, it can be seen that this would be feasible – without tolls or lockage fees.
     

    The Author
    James A. Kearns is a Partner at Bryan Cave LLP. Mr. Kearns has represented owners, operators, financial institutions (as both lessors and lenders), and end users for more than 30 years in the purchase, construction and financing of vessels engaged in both the foreign and coastwise trades of the United States, including compliance with the requirements of the Jones Act for the ownership, chartering and transfer of vessels. Kearns has earned an LL.M. (in Taxation), New York University, J.D. cum laude, University of Notre Dame, 1974, and a B.S.E.E., summa cum laude, University of Notre Dame, 1971. Reach him at jakearns@bryancave.com
     
     
    (As published in the September 2016 edition of Marine News)

  • , 2012 enactment of the Iran Threat Reduction and Syria Human Rights Act of 2012 (the ITRA), which included amendments to the Iran Sanctions Act of 1996 (the ISA), the Comprehensive Iran Sanctions, Accountability and Divestment Act of 2010 (CISADA), and the National Defense Authorization Act For Fiscal Year 2012

  • for their high manganese content. In one area of the North Pacific Ocean seabed known as the Clarion Clipper Zone, the International Seabed Authority (ISA) estimates there are over 20 billion tons of these nodules. Generally, these nodules lie atop ocean sediment at depths greater than 3000 meters.Seafloor

  • of intrinsically safe systems in marine applications will be explored in a two-day short course sponsored by the Instrument Society of America (ISA). The course will be held at the Sheraton National Motor Hotel, Washington, D.C., June 27-28, 1977. Conducted by experts from key marine areas

  • sizes, with either cast iron, cast steel, or stainlesssteel bodies, with threaded or ANSI f l a n g e d - e n d connections that conform to standard ISA face-to-face dimensions. These versatile, general-purpose valves are designed for use in steam, water, air, gas, and liquid applications. Size

  • symmetries. The recently re-developed solution FSYSD for the diagrams definition adds functionality, such as new instrumentation lines according with ANSI/ISA-S5-1-1984/1992 regulation. The communications with other systems has been improved and now it is possible to export multiple diagrams in PDF format

  • rate of a few millimeters every million years.   As the CCZ is in international waters, it falls under the mandate of the International Seabed Authority (ISA). So far, there have been 16 mining exploration areas allocated, each roughly the size of Panama (up to 75,000 km2). Nodules can be harvested relatively

  • The Arab Shipbuilding and Repair Yard Co. (ASRY) was inaugurated at a ceremony presided over by His Highness the Ruler of Bahrain. The Ruler, Shaikh Isa bin Sulman Al-Khalifa, blessed the yard by pouring holy water from the Well at Zam Zam into the drydock and declared it officially open. His Highness

  • A new U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) report describes how advanced optical sensor technology is being used in the Mississippi River basin to accurately track the nitrate pulse to the Gulf of Mexico. Excessive springtime nitrate runoff from agricultural land and other sources in the Mississippi drainage

  • New international standards for double hull oil tanker construction were recently adopted at the 32nd session of the Marine Environment Protection Committee (MEPC 32) of the International Maritime Organization (IMO), a United Nations agency responsible for maritime affairs. U.S. Coast Guard Rear Adm.

  • Scorpion Ribs is a boat maker, and its Scorpion Sting can also provide proof of the ride quality and performance courtesy of data obtained using the Dyena Acceleration Recorder. The Dyena Acceleration Recorder (DaccR) is proving to be a valuable tool for the development and comparison of fast boats. Tradition

  • The scale of future independent tanker operations and the long-term role of independent tanker owners is the theme which forms the basis of Study No. 49, "The Role of Independent Tanker Owners," by H.P. Drewry (Shipping Consultants) Limited of London, England. In order to establish the different

  • MN Dec-19#24 construction of the third san disagreement on the use of military)
    December 2019 - Marine News page: 24

    bill also contains an addi- FY 2020, which remains stalled in the Senate over parti- tional $300 million to fund the construction of the third san disagreement on the use of military funding for the National Security Multi-Mission Vessel (NSMV), which border wall and other issues, nevertheless also

  • MR Dec-19#29 GREAT SHIPS OF 2019 A METHANOL FUTURE LESSONS LEARNED Tips)
    December 2019 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 29

    GREAT SHIPS OF 2019 A METHANOL FUTURE LESSONS LEARNED Tips on designing, building & operating with methanol as fuel. Generally averse to technologi- requires a small amount of pilot fuel second-generation of MAN methanol 2. VESSEL CONSTRUCTION cal risk, maritime professionals lean “Go to an established

  • MR Dec-19#17 S SOFTWARE SOLUTIONS which you can infer aspects of a)
    December 2019 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 17

    S SOFTWARE SOLUTIONS which you can infer aspects of a vessel’s condition. go periodical surveys by their ? ag state administra- no surprises, no off-hire. Just the provision of consis- However, even with all these sources, you can’t get a tion or classi? cation society and are therefore legally tent

  • MR Dec-19#16 S SOFTWARE SOLUTIONS Tapio Hulkkonen (left) is the)
    December 2019 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 16

    S SOFTWARE SOLUTIONS Tapio Hulkkonen (left) is the Director of Product Management at NAPA Design Solutions. His experi- ence includes 23 years working at shipyards in Finland and now 14 years at NAPA. Teemu Mander- backa is a Senior R&D Engineer at NAPA Shipping Solutions. He has a background in experimental

  • MR Dec-19#8 I INSIGHTS: TRAINING TIPS FOR SHIPS Murray Goldberg is CEO)
    December 2019 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 8

    I INSIGHTS: TRAINING TIPS FOR SHIPS Murray Goldberg is CEO of Marine Learning Systems which provides software and services to optimize knowledge, skills and behavior in maritime operators. In his former life he was a computer science faculty member at the University of BC researching online learning and

  • MT Nov-19#24 water ran-s3.s3.amazonaws.com/isa.org.jm/ Support Vessel)
    November 2019 - Marine Technology Reporter page: 24

    mining support Regulations can be found here https:// For many, the Solwara 1 Production vessel or rig at the surface, the water ran-s3.s3.amazonaws.com/isa.org.jm/ Support Vessel which was built and must be removed and returned to the s3fs-public/? les/documents/isba24_ltc- launched at Fujian Mawei Shipyard

  • MT Nov-19#23 . In the ensuing years, the ISA has which fall outside)
    November 2019 - Marine Technology Reporter page: 23

    from own legislation to govern mining. For any harmful effects of mining opera- the many areas of commercial interest tions. In the ensuing years, the ISA has which fall outside these coastal state promulgated prospecting and explora- boundaries; the United Nations Con- tion regulations for all types

  • MT Nov-19#21 of ocean minerals. ity (ISA) estimates there are over)
    November 2019 - Marine Technology Reporter page: 21

    mining starts in earnest. seabed known as the Clarion Clipper Zone, the International Seabed Author- Types of ocean minerals. ity (ISA) estimates there are over 20 There are three types of deep-sea billion tons of these nodules. Generally, ocean minerals of commercial interest;

  • MT Nov-19#14 Dr. Mathias Jonas, Secretary General, IHO oices I think it)
    November 2019 - Marine Technology Reporter page: 14

    Dr. Mathias Jonas, Secretary General, IHO oices I think it is generally agreed that across all maritime science, engineering ing processes like digitalization, im- these are times of heightened geo- and administration domains. The princi- provement of technology and increased political unrest. If you

  • MR Nov-19#54 ENVIRONMENTAL GREEN SHIP RECYCLING n May 2014 National)
    November 2019 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 54

    ENVIRONMENTAL GREEN SHIP RECYCLING n May 2014 National Geograph- is tremendous pressure from both gov- The Wrong Way to Recycle A Vessels a cash buyer, the new owner will use a ic wrote an in-depth article on ernment regulators and within the ship- To place pressure on both shipowners number of different

  • MR Nov-19#41 WORKBOATS SOUTHERN TOWING COMPANY “No vessel can maneuver)
    November 2019 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 41

    WORKBOATS SOUTHERN TOWING COMPANY “No vessel can maneuver a tow into or out of a dock as good as the Z drive. And then you start talking about bumps and bruises on your barges, a lot of which come when you’re docking and undocking ... the safety contribution that Z-drives makes to marine transpor- tation

  • MN Nov-19#84 CAD/CAM SOFTWARE Software Tools for Propeller Professiona)
    November 2019 - Marine News page: 84

    CAD/CAM SOFTWARE Software Tools for Propeller Professionals TrueProp is software for propeller inspection devices, assisting propeller manufacturers and repair shops to identify damage, repair and tune propellers to improve performance and save fuel. By Adam Kaplan aving the right tools for the

  • MP Q3-19#18 SOFTWARE SOLUTIONS HOW WELL DO YOU KNOW YOUR SHIPS?)
    Sep/Oct 2019 - Maritime Logistics Professional page: 18

    SOFTWARE SOLUTIONS HOW WELL DO YOU KNOW YOUR SHIPS? Collaboratively use existing technologies and data to fnd valuable information about a ship’s actual condition. Eventually, this leads to positive changes in vessel performance and optimization. Is that too much to ask? By Tapio Hulkkonen and

  • MP Q3-19#15 When the TOS tide comes in, all the boats foat. It isn’t)
    Sep/Oct 2019 - Maritime Logistics Professional page: 15

    When the TOS tide comes in, all the boats foat. It isn’t hard to see why. ter years of experience as the technology division for Carrix, Inc., space is the integrated ability to leverage ‘big data’ produced by ter- which operates in more than 250 locations worldwide. With this minal operations. This

  • MP Q3-19#10 OP/ED SCRUBBERS: the Best Option for IMO 2020 Compliance 20)
    Sep/Oct 2019 - Maritime Logistics Professional page: 10

    OP/ED SCRUBBERS: the Best Option for IMO 2020 Compliance 2020 has been described as the most signifcant USD $100-300 per tonne more than HSFO. In Rotterdam, the price environmental regulation ever implemented for spread between LSFO and HSFO is forecast to widen to between IMO the oil industry, as from

  • MR Oct-19#60 T THOUGHT LEADERSHIP CLASSIFICATION ABS & the Future of)
    October 2019 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 60

    T THOUGHT LEADERSHIP CLASSIFICATION ABS & the Future of Classi? cation By Greg Trauthwein Photo: ABS The discussion of the ‘future of class’ certainty and unpredictability, Wiernicki designed, built and operated going impetus to proceed at pace. seems more relevant today than ever, as counts the impact

  • MN Sep-19#45 DYNAMIC POSITIONING “DP will be just as important to the)
    September 2019 - Marine News page: 45

    DYNAMIC POSITIONING “DP will be just as important to the offshore wind market as it is to offshore oil and gas. Both need a stable, well positioned vessel to provide equipment, support, maintenance and supplies to the offshore structures.” – Ben Todd, Vice President and COO, Beier Integrated Systems (Ph

  • MN Oct-19#27 Illinois Soybean Association (ISA). some remaining work)
    October 2019 - Marine News page: 27

    products and 4 million tons of fertil- upgrades in 2020. Most work concludes next summer, but izer, according to the Illinois Soybean Association (ISA). some remaining work is planned out until 2023 – 90 years About 60% of the soybeans grown in IL are exported. Wa- after ribbon-cutting. The upcoming

  • MN Oct-19#12 BY THE NUMBERS lacking. Perhaps the most recent safety)
    October 2019 - Marine News page: 12

    BY THE NUMBERS lacking. Perhaps the most recent safety numbers means Since 2001 – the high water mark for registered do- that they are making progress. Let’s hope so. mestic recreational hulls – the number of boating deaths As it continually addresses the issue of boating safety, the has decreased about

  • MN Mar-19#42 SAFETY four of the TPOs and have watched our customers)
    March 2019 - Marine News page: 42

    SAFETY four of the TPOs and have watched our customers learn. Sea change We have seen the auditors teach the mariners and reinforce Sub M is a sea change for the industry. You can’t contin- our message. We have seen companies improve. The TSMS ue to operate in the manner that you have always done it.

  • MR Sep-19#19 T THOUGHT LEADERSHIP: PORT & SHIP SECURITY T 10 A HE TH)
    September 2019 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 19

    T THOUGHT LEADERSHIP: PORT & SHIP SECURITY T 10 A HE TH NNUAL M R ARITIME ISK S YMPOSIUM is scheduled for Nov. 13-15, 2019, at SUNY Maritime in New York. www.sunymaritime.edu about the spill and analyze its future movement, and how best to deploy assets from unmanned aerial vehicles to Vessels of

  • MR Sep-19#13 I INSIGHTS: FSRU to onshore regasi? cation, opening new)
    September 2019 - Maritime Reporter and Engineering News page: 13

    I INSIGHTS: FSRU to onshore regasi? cation, opening new LNG supply: there needs to be a com- ers is to develop small-scale LNG proj- speculative ordering of FSRUs is slow- markets the possibility of importing liq- mitment to provide minimum volumes, ects that meet all these requirements ing, although

  • MT Sep-19#54 the assigned a time to disassemble and a new position)
    September 2019 - Marine Technology Reporter page: 54

    the water.” same spot and if it needs to move. Each moving CVP is then To reach that goal, the researchers are further developing the assigned a time to disassemble and a new position in the new roboats to ensure they can safely hold people, and are robust shape. to all weather conditions, such as heavy

  • MP Q3-19#18 STATISTICS C NK’ P S C A RLASS S ORT TATE ONTROL)
    Jul/Aug 2019 - Maritime Logistics Professional page: 18

    STATISTICS C NK’ P S C A RLASS S ORT TATE ONTROL NNUAL EPORT lassi? cation society ClassNK in July released its annual Tokyo MOU report on Port State Control. The report aims to assist ship Also according to the Tokyo MOU annual report, in cases Coperators and management companies in maintaining