Today’s workboat operators must navigate increasingly stringent IMO and EPA environmental and emissions regulations in and around ports and rivers. As the drama unfolds, selective catalytic reduction or SCR is emerging as a viable vehicle to do just that. At the same time, fears about space constraints for smaller vessels and the hassle of carrying and handing urea for these systems are rapidly evaporating, as well.
Two different firms – both familiar names in propulsion markets – have embraced SCR as the way forward. Both, Tenneco and Volvo Penta, rely on deep roots in these markets and significant experience in the effort to reduce emissions from engines. For its part, Volvo Penta is a recognized stakeholder in the marine propulsion markets, while Tenneco is widely known for its deep roots in emissions reduction in the automotive sector. It now brings that expertise to the water, just in time for workboat operators thirsting for a compact, effective and class-approved solution.
Already a leading global supplier of Clean Air aftertreatment technologies in other sectors, Tenneco was in July awarded three product design assessment (PDA) certificates from the American Bureau of Shipping for its new selective catalytic reduction (SCR) system for large engines. That said; Tenneco’s SCR solution is already out on the water, performing as advertised, on not one but two workboat hulls.
Tim Jackson, Tenneco’s head of Technology, told MarineNews, “Tenneco’s core business in clean air technologies began in 1975 with light vehicle solutions for the passenger car and light truck market. We expanded to commercial trucks in 2004, and by 2010, developed our first SCR systems for locomotives and for off-highway equipment. In 2012 we developed our first marine and stationary power systems and in 2014 launched our first complete marine SCR aftertreatment system.” Beyond this says Jackson, Tenneco is working to provide solutions for our customers to meet future regulations such as EU Stage 5.”
Tenneco’s SCR aftertreatment system features a complete dosing control solution specifically designed for marine engine applications up to 7,500 kW or 10,000 hp. The system is designed to enable propulsion and auxiliary engines to meet EPA Tier IV and IMO Tier III regulatory requirements and provide precise and reliable delivery of liquid urea via a proprietary, high-performance injector design, a precision mechatronic fluid delivery pump and customizable remote monitoring and controls.
In the past year, field tests were conducted on a 224 foot Great Lakes training vessel powered by four 800 horsepower, circa 1984 Tier 0 engines.
In a series of validation tests, including the ISO 8178 E2 cycle, when one of the engines was outfitted with the aftertreatment system, the engine met all criteria for IMO Tier III including NOx and SOx. In 2015, additional field tests are currently underway on the sister vessel – the training vessel of the Texas Maritime Academy, powered by the same type of engines. Initial testing produced results which meet EPA Tier IV emission levels. In August, MarineNews traveled to the Texas A&M Maritime Academy in Galveston, TX to see the installation up close, and talk with company officials about the results.
The SCR system’s modular design enables seamless integration for a broad range of engine sizes and works with electrically or mechanically controlled engines. In two retrofit installations – both in enginerooms with limited physical room – the system has been proven in a wide array of installation options. Better known in automotive markets, Lake Forest, IL-based Tenneco is nevertheless one of the world’s largest designers, manufacturers and marketers of clean air products for automotive and commercial vehicle original equipment markets and the aftermarket.
At Texas A&M, similar to its earlier successes at the Great Lakes Maritime Academy, Tenneco’s SCR solution is helping the school meet new emissions regulations. Both the TS General Rudder, which is operated by the Maritime Academy and its Great Lakes sister vessel employ 33-year old 800 horsepower, Tier 0 engines. The Tenneco solution has been demonstrated to keep both engines compliant with today’s stringent EPA Tier IV marine emission requirements under all operational conditions.
Because space is at a premium on workboats, Tenneco leveraged its packaging expertise in passenger car and commercial vehicle aftertreatment systems to develop a highly compact and flexible system for the large engine marine market. Indeed, Tenneco’s large engine SCR can be integrated into a variety of engine designs. Jackson adds, “Our SCR Reactor can be installed vertically or horizontally in-line with existing engine exhaust piping. The dosing control system is compact and can be mounted in a variety of locations. Urea pump supports flows of up to 120 meters, which enables a range of installation options for urea storage.”
Ideal for newbuild tonnage, the modular system is compact and can be integrated with a variety of engines, engine room configurations and retrofits. According to Jackson, installation is straightforward and can be completed as part of a planned maintenance update. And, he says, additional validation testing is underway in Asia and Europe, and the system is currently being validated with marine and large engine customers.
Urea consumption – always a concern and an expense for any operator – depends on a number of factors including engine configuration, the level of NOx reduction required and duty cycle, but a good rule of thumb is urea consumption of approximately 3-5% of fuel consumption. The urea is completely consumed in the aftertreatment process, so there is nothing to be disposed.
Commenting on the cost of the urea, Jackson insists, “Urea consumption is a small fraction of fuel consumption. Also, the use of SCR to meet emissions requirements versus exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) technology typically allows the engine to be tuned for lower fuel consumption, so urea consumption and cost can often be offset with fuel savings.
Tenneco’s Jackson sees a bright future for SCR on the water. “We see broad application for our SCR system in the workboat market including push boats, tugs, pilot boats, offshore support vessels, rescue vessels, dredges and commercial fishing boats as well as offshore drilling rigs themselves.” And, he adds, “We bring decades of integration and packaging experience to every marine engine application we design. The result is an SCR aftertreatment system that is easy to install, economical to use, and simple to maintain.”
Volvo Penta of the Americas
Volvo Penta’s strategy for emissions control in marine diesel engines, as it applies to its power range of high-speed commercial marine diesel applications (less than 600KW), also involves Selective Catalytic Reduction. Citing reliability and the lowest total cost of ownership, Ron Huibers, President, Volvo Penta of the Americas, adds, “We have determined that this is the best solution for its ability to reduce emissions to meet the most stringent current and projected regulations in North America and internationally.”
Actually, says, Huibers, the Volvo Group was one of the pioneers with SCR technology, dating back to 2005. And like Tenneco, Volvo has many years of experience in deploying SCR on trucks, buses and offroad vehicles – as well as marine vessels - with proven SCR technology that meets the world’s toughest emission standards. According to Huibers, SCR allows Volvo to sustain high power outputs without performance compromises. Beyond, he says, “Our SCR solution allows us to meet emission requirements without an additional diesel particulate filter (DPF).”
Committed to SCR, Volvo Penta is also teaming with STT Emtec in repowering some 50 sightseeing canal boats in Amsterdam to achieve the goal of zero emissions. In this case, however, the Volvo Penta D5A TA engines were fitted with a marine exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) solution that reduces NOx by diluting the charge air with recirculated exhaust gas. Using the system, the engine’s carbon monoxide, hydrocarbon and carbon particle emissions are reduced by up to 60 percent and NOx emissions by up to 45 percent. The system has not yet been deployed in North America, but Volvo Penta will respond to requests, if the market evolves.
Here in the United States, Volvo Penta’s range of commercial marine diesels are less than 600 KW and meet EPA Tier 3 without SCR. And Volvo says that to retrofit SCR on its existing uncatalyzed engines is not yet practical. In other markets, Volvo has employed EGR in combination with SCR, specifically in their on-highway US EPA 2010 rule and offroad market, Tier 4 Final.
Like Tenneco, Volvo Penta is carefully looking at the limited engineroom space on workboats. Huibers explains, “While EGR is slightly smaller in installation, SCR makes it possible for us to keep our high power outputs and is better suited to take care of the high sulfur contents of marine diesel. We are targeting to reduce the physical dimensions of our SCR solution by 30-50 percent in the future.”
Like Tenneco, Volvo Penta puts urea consumption at roughly 3 percent of annual fuel consumption, depending on the duty cycle. Huibers adds, “We are optimizing our engines and urea dosing strategies to make the end result cost neutral to the user when it comes to urea and fuel versus EPA Tier 3 levels.”
Different boats, Different Longsplices
Every situation and business case is different. U.S. EPA Tier IV regulations apply to new vessels, and the costs and benefits of engine configuration and aftertreatment should be taken into consideration based on the operators’ individual needs. The U.S. EPA Tier IV regulation requiring NOx reduction started in 2014. Notably, Tenneco’s aftertreatment systems enable engines to comply with the IMO and EPA regulations.
For a workboat operator contemplating (a.) newbuild, (b.) repower and/or (c.) merely adding SCR to an existing engine, the choices can be confusing. Tenneco’s Jackson sums up the equation succinctly, saying, “While there are costs associated with all powertrain technology upgrades, an SCR system would be a fraction of the cost of a new or remanufactured engine.” Tenneco’s money is on SCR, and Volvo Penta is on the same course. And, it is difficult to argue with either OEM. That’s because, when it comes to emissions management, experience counts.
(As published in the October 2015 edition of Marine News - http://magazines.marinelink.com/Magazines/MaritimeNews)
16V 4000 M63L propulsion engines, each delivering 2,000 kW, a 16-cylinder 4000 M23F diesel genset rated at 1,520 kW, and the SCR system. The exhaust aftertreatment system, with selective catalytic reduction (SCR) technology, is connected to the diesel genset. The tests on the Fairplay tug, which will run
from Germany delivers an insightful look (starting on page 26) at Color Line and its efforts in retrofitting its modern ferries with exhaust aftertreatment scrubber technology in its mission to meet and beat new emission rules. (As published in the July 2014 edition of Maritime Reporter & Engineering
Eastern Shipbuilding’s forward-thinking inland towboat design now features CAT Tier 4 propulsion and aftertreatment. When Eastern Shipbuilding Group (ESG) introduced its cutting edge 4,000 hp Thunderbolt inland towboat designed around twin azimuthing AAA Propulsion electric V-Pod propulsion and diesel-ele
the maritime industry. For example, Cummins has been involved in meeting complex on-highway emissions for more than 20 years. Our early adaptation of aftertreatment solutions for the on-highway market, whose strict emissions regulations are ahead of most, has carried over to our marine solutions.In addition
regulations through a combination of in-cylinder engine improvements, exhaust gas recirculation (EGR), selective catalytic reduction (SCR) exhaust aftertreatment and diesel oxidation catalyst (DOC). These engines do not require the use of a diesel particulate filter (DPF) to meet the new air quality standards
. The lean burn combustion of gaseous fuels is an enabler of both the low emissions and high efficiencies of WinGD low-speed DF engines. Even without aftertreatment their NOx emissions in gas operation mode are within the limits set by IMO TIER III for vessels operating in Emissions Control Areas (ECAs), while
offshore industries, Caterpillar’s Tier 4 platforms combine fuel efficiency (approximate 5% fuel reduction) with selective catalytic reduction (SRC) aftertreatment system to meet the Tier 4 NOx requirements. Though Cat said it anticipates expanding its Tier 4 compliant line with the launch of several additional
on electrification, digitalization and connectivity.”The ‘conventional’ option involves installing two large EPA Tier 4 main engines supplemented by an aftertreatment system – either the Exhaust Gas Recirculation (EGR) or Selective Catalyst Reduction (SCR) option. The latter choice can add additional piping,
?Thermamax is a specialist in the design and manufacture of thermal and acoustic insulation solutions for diesel engines, spark ignited engines, exhaust aftertreatment systems and electric storage systems. Our markets include automotive, on- and off-highway sectors, power sports vehicles, stationary power generation
engines as opposed to two – smaller individual power units giving a total combined power similar to that of two larger engines but without requiring aftertreatment. And the tangible benefit is that you can actually operate at slower speeds using only one or two engines. It’s a far more efficient way of running
comparing medium speed to high speed engines – see table 5), but, says Hatton, “There’s no comparison when you consider the added weight of the aftertreatment system and urea.” On any workboat, however, space is always a concern. GE’s Tier 4 engine has increased incrementally in weight and volume
MR Professional www.MaritimeProfessional.com Technology Associates, Inc. Bringing Engineering to Successful Fruition ? Naval Architecture Services ? Marine Engineering ? Design Services ?ŽY?l??ÐOŽYEwsYs?l?AOŽY ? Regulatory Liaison ?/Y?ÐGÐOŽY?AYE^??|G?
This directory section is an editorial feature published in every issue for the convenience of the readers of MARITIME REPORTER. A quick-reference readers’ guide, it includes the names and addresses of the world’s leading manufacturers and suppliers of all types of marine machinery, equipment, supplies and
P PRODUCTS NEW FROM NORSHIPPING MIROS Speed Through Water OSM Maritime’s OSM ON Miros launched Miros Speed Through Water, a OSM Maritime dry-mounted, radar-based system. “Access to ac- introduces OSM curate speed through water data will enable im- ON, which uses provements in the application of ship
and add a Selective Catalytic Reduction ExxonMobil added Mobilgard M420 to its range larly suited for medium-speed main or auxiliary (SCR) aftertreatment system. A unique feature of advanced marine lubricants. Mobilgard M420 engines burning fuels with sulfur contents up to will allow the ship’s
P PRODUCTS NEW FROM NORSHIPPING Wärtsilä Unveils Navi-Planner Wärtsilä unveiled its new Navi-Planner voyage planning and optimization solution, developed by Transas, a Wärtsilä company. The new Navi- Planner makes use of the connected ECDIS. The new connectivity allows tedious onboard voyage planning
T TRADE SHOW NORSHIPPING 2019 was for a 14,000 TEU container ship. closely behind, there was a palpable by arti? cial intelligence and underlying data infrastructure”, Kongsberg Vessel Each vessel design was modi? ed from a tension from maritime stakeholders at- algorithms. Insight is a combination
T TRADE SHOW NORSHIPPING 2019 lished by the UN Global Compact, a UN sponsored group to assist companies in aligning their operations with UN principles, the strategy laid out 17 “Global Goals” divided into the categories of a healthy, produc- tive, and well-governed oceans. “All the 17 goals are deeply
T TRADE SHOW NORSHIPPING 2019 sels. Once the Yara Birkeland and ACS stated that “the ship is not depending on ing satellite communications company gration for autonomous marine compo- are placed into operation, the command interfacing with the shore control”. Rath- INMARSAT, Monohakobi Technology nents.
T TRADE SHOW NORSHIPPING 2019 Photo: Greg Trauthwein NorShipping: A “Koselig” Event By Joseph DiRenzo, PE a gathering of competitors keen on siz- helmsen’s main of? ce in Lyskaer. ing one another up and more of a gather- Tom Eystø, CEO of Masstery, said the AUTOMATION KOSELIG ing of old colleagues and
T TECH FILES ROBOTICS & DRONES ‘Blade Crawlers’ Could help to keep offshore wind farms generating Drones and crawling robots out? tted photos and looking for visible damage, tions that may signal larger, subsurface spot so that the location of subsurface with special scanning technology could like
T TECH FILES FUTURE FUELS Rendering of a bulk carrier for the trans- portation of lique? ed hydrogen by Moss Maritime, Wilhelmsen Ship Management, Equinor, and DNV-GL. Photo credit: Moss Maritime. fjords, Svalbard, the austere arctic island ing capability. CAPEX and OPEX” said Mr. Skogan. A
T TECH FILES FUTURE FUELS Hydrogen: The rise of bulk Hydrogen in Norway By Joseph DiRenzo, PE Imagine a power distribution network where excess renewable energy from hydropower, wind, solar, and nuclear energy is converted to hydrogen and used as transportation fuel in the mari- time industry. With the
N BY THE NUMBERS $60B The estimated annual potential cost of the move to low-sulfur fuel. “The switch to low-sulfur fuel will require operational and engineering actions, which, if not done properly, can have a wide-ranging impact. The switch will also have wider implications for the fuel supply chain
N BY THE NUMBERS SHIPPING LOSSES DROP, NEW DANGERS EMERGE As the maritime industry digests a host Emissions Compliance of new emission and fuel regulations, in On the regulatory side, emissions com- tandem with a fast-evolving technologi- pliance, most immediately in regards to cal evolution that
A CAPABLE USCG INVESTING IN SHIPS & BOATS “The Coast Guard is building ships. We’re planning to build 25 Offshore Patrol Cutters, we’re still building Fast Re- “I want a Ready, Responsive and Relevant sponse Cutters, we’re building National Security Cutters, we’re positioned to start building Waterways
Offshore Wind One-stop power conversion With the United States and China about to start their respective offshore wind build-ups, grid operators wondering about the ef? ciency of their turbines or the emissions-areas compliance of their wind-service vessels will be warmed to know there’s someone they can
S SOFTWARE: THOUGHT LEADERSHIP Reclaim your ‘in’ box s the most universal method nied a connection. B FLEET ARE of electronic communication After a connection is established with MONITORING yet devised, e-mail is ines- a reputable mail relay server, each in- FOR RED Acapable – even at sea. Yet its
S SOFTWARE: THOUGHT LEADERSHIP Compass leads the way As YILPORT Rolls Out the Navis’ Compass Visual Work? ow Management Application, the collaborative tool promises improved planning and greater visibility across ? ve terminals. And, that’s just the beginning. By Joseph Keefe n May, Navis announced that
D DESIGN: BACK TO THE DRAWING BOARD Figure 2: Sketch of WISES, the 100+ Knot Vessel Soviets made a signifcant investment in this concept, but it stalled during Glas- nost. Interestingly, new technologies such as composites, digital fight control, and much better engines, could move this concept ahead
D DESIGN: BACK TO THE DRAWING BOARD Rik van Hemmen Rik van Hemmen is the President of Martin & Ottaway, a marine consulting frm that specializes in the resolution of technical, opera- tional and fnancial issues in maritime. By training he is an Aerospace and Ocean engineer and has spent the majority of his
I INSIGHTS: GHG EMISSIONS can quickly change the paradigm and improved vessel utilization, less addi- have vessels speed up to meet supply tional capacity would be required. Like- chain demands. wise, digital technology and improved It is results such as these which likely connectivity will support next
I INSIGHTS: GHG EMISSIONS Gurinder Singh Gurinder Singh is Director of Global Sustainability, at ABS. Course to Low Carbon Shipping n a collective call to action for the decarbonization of shipping last year, 34 signatory CEOs from the Iindustry made clear that efforts to signi? cantly lower the
I INSIGHTS: GOVERNMENT UPDATE Dennis L. Bryant Dennis Bryant is with Bryant’s Maritime Consulting, and a regular contributor to Maritime Reporter & Engineering News as well as online at MaritimeLogisticsProfessional.com. email@example.com Maritime’s Cyber Alert or some years now, the mari- time
MARITIME Editorial REPORTER AND ENGINEERING NEWS M A R I N E L I N K . C O M HQ 118 E. 25th St., 2nd Floor New York, NY 10010 USA Tel +1 212 477 6700 Fax +1 212 254 6271 www.marinelink.com FL Of? ce 215 NW 3rd St Boynton Beach, FL 33435-4009 Tel +1 561 732 4368 Fax +1 561 732 6984 Publisher John C.