Just recently, we had an opportunity to discuss the Coast Guard’s Administrative Law Judge Program with its Chief Judge, Walter J. Brudzinski. Judge Brudzinski has been a Coast Guard Administrative Law Judge since 2003 and was appointed Chief Judge in June 2013. We caught up with him this summer in Washington and asked him to describe what an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) is, what the Coast Guard’s ALJ Program does, how he got to be where he is, and his vision for leading this Program.
Administrative Law Judges:
There are thirty federal agencies with Administrative Law Judges, including the Coast Guard. The number of ALJs per agency varies from approximately 1,400 at Social Security to just one at the U.S. Postal Service. The Coast Guard is authorized for seven. Administrative Law Judges are appointed pursuant to 5 U.S.C. § 3105 and accompanying regulations and these laws provide for strict controls on employing agencies to ensure decisional independence.
Appointments are made with U.S. Office of Personnel Management oversight using a competitive process. Judges are provided special civil service protections and the expectation of lifetime careers. Agencies may not control ALJ’s salaries, conduct performance reviews, or provide monetary/honorary awards.
In the exercise of their judicial functions, ALJs retain decisional independence within the limits of law, regulations, and agency appeal decisions. They exercise independent judgment and can review the evidence before them free from pressures of the parties or officials within the agency.
The Coast Guard’s ALJ Program:
Coast Guard Administrative Law Judges primarily adjudicate Merchant Mariner Credential Suspension and Revocation (S&R) cases. Coast Guard Investigating Officers initiate S&R cases against mariners for negligence, misconduct, incompetence, violation of law or regulation, and use of dangerous drugs.
Respondent-mariners may appear with an attorney, a non-attorney representative, or self-represent. They may call witnesses, introduce documentary evidence, cross-examine Coast Guard witnesses, and submit rebuttal evidence. The Judge’s decision is final unless appealed to the Commandant. Further appeals can be made to the National Transportation Safety Bureau (NTSB) and to an appropriate U.S. Court of Appeals.
The purpose of S&R proceedings is to promote safety at sea. Often confused with the criminal justice court system, S&R actions against merchant mariners’ credentials are remedial and not penal in nature. They are intended to help maintain standards for competence and conduct essential to the promotion of safety at sea.
The Coast Guard ALJ Program disposes of approximately 600 cases each year. The overwhelming majority of S&R cases involve use of dangerous drugs and most cases are disposed of by settlement agreement. The remaining cases are disposed of at hearing which are conducted in a similar fashion to trials in federal court without a jury.
Coast Guard Administrative Law Judges are also authorized to adjudicate Class II civil penalties assessed under the Federal Water Pollution Control Act and the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act. Coast Guard Judges also adjudicate cases initiated by agencies within the Department of Homeland Security and other agencies the Coast Guard supports. These cases are adjudicated on a reimbursable basis, pursuant to law, and as caseloads permit. For example, in 2003-2004, Chief Judge Brudzinski was temporarily assigned additional duties to hear cases for the 9/11 Victim Compensation Fund. Coast Guard Administrative Law Judge are located in Seattle, WA, Alameda, CA, Galveston, TX, New Orleans, LA, Baltimore, MD, and New York, NY. The Chief Administrative Law Judge is located in Washington, DC.
How he got there:
Chief Judge Brudzinski was initially appointed U.S. Administrative Law Judge in 1996 with the Social Security Administration. He was previously an Assistant and later Deputy Commonwealth’s Attorney for Virginia Beach. Prior to his prosecutorial career, he served in the U.S. Coast Guard as a commissioned officer both afloat and ashore and in various legal assignments as a judge advocate.
During his last judge advocate assignment, he also served as Special Assistant U.S. Attorney. He is a graduate of the University of Maryland and the George Mason University School of Law (with distinction) where he was a member of Law Review. Chief Judge Brudzinski also holds a Master’s and Ph.D. in Judicial Studies from the University of Nevada and has earned Certificates in Judicial Development in Administrative Law, Dispute Resolution, and General Jurisdiction Trial Skills from the National Judicial College. He attributes his success as a Coast Guard Judge to his litigation background, Coast Guard experience, the professional training programs at the National Judicial College, and the academically rigorous Judicial Studies Program at the University of Nevada.
As Coast Guard’s Chief Administrative Law Judge, he is widely published and has authored many articles in a wide variety of venues, trade journals and other publications. Chief Judge Brudzinski was admitted to practice in Virginia, Maryland, and Pennsylvania; the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia; the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit; the Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces; and, the Supreme Court of the United States. His professional affiliations include the American Bar Association – Judicial Division; the Federal Administrative Law Judges Conference; the National Association of Administrative Law Judiciary; the Maritime Law Association of the United States; and, the Connecticut Maritime Association.
Vision for Leading the Program:
Chief Judge Brudzinski’s vision for the Coast Guard ALJ Program is simple: “We are dedicated to performing our judicial duties fairly, impartially, and in a manner that secures the trust and confidence of the regulated community, the agency, and the general public. We secure that trust and confidence by treating the parties with respect and by issuing clear decisions and orders the public understands and accepts as correct, fair, and well-reasoned.”
Brudzinski’s vision reflects the ALJ’s Organizational Goals which promise fast, impartial, and well reasoned judicial services; to clarify agency policy concerning cases brought before them; to promote confidence in the administrative adjudicative process; and, to create an atmosphere in which the parties recognize they have been dealt with fairly.
To maintain the highest standards of quality in their written decisions, Coast Guard Judges receive training at the National Judicial College. They also subject their written work products to rigorous editing and review to ensure legal sufficiency and clarity.
Of note are two ongoing initiatives being addressed by Coast Guard judges. The first initiative is to further ensure due process for unrepresented mariner-respondents. Brudzinski says, “We do this by facilitating opportunities for them to obtain representation from attorneys that have previously indicated to us they are willing to represent mariners at no cost.” The second initiative is to have Coast Guard attorneys appear at hearings on a regular basis, in addition to the Investigating Officer. Brudzinski explains, “Coast Guard S&R proceedings are adversarial and our experience has shown that the process works best when both sides are represented by counsel. These two initiatives will improve the overall quality of the S&R process and we expect them to be finalized in the near future.”
(As published in the 3Q 2014 edition of Maritime Professional - www.maritimeprofessional.com)
Index page MTR MarApr2024:MTR Layouts 4/4/2024 3:19 PM Page 1 Advertiser Index PageCompany Website Phone# 17 . . . . .Airmar Technology Corporation . . . . . . . . . .www.airmar.com . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(603) 673-9570 9 . . . . . .Birns, Inc. . . . . . . . . . .
ronments. The new agreement will address speci? c techni- cal gaps in the UUV defense and offshore energy markets especially for long duration, multi-payload mission opera- tions where communications are often denied or restricted. As part of the new alliance, Metron’s Resilient Mission Autonomy portfolio
from marinas along the western coast. The exact number of lizing laser detection systems can detect mines just below the mines, as well as their locations, remains largely a mystery, surface, even those hiding in murky water. The Airborne Laser although reports suggest that over three hundred have been
MTR Editorial Advisors Gallaudet Hardy The Honorable Tim Gallaudet, Kevin Hardy is President PhD, Rear Admiral, U.S. of Global Ocean Design, Navy (ret) is the CEO of creating components and Ocean STL Consulting and subsystems for unmanned host of The American Blue vehicles, following a career
Editorial NIWA-Nippon Foundation TESMaP/ Rebekah Parsons-King www.marinetechnologynews.com ast month marked the resounding NEW YORK 118 E. 25th St., New York, NY 10010 return of Oceanology Interna- Tel: (212) 477-6700; Fax: (212) 254-6271 tional in London, perennially one Lof the world’s most important
Your Specialist Ofshore Lubricant Partner T Togeth her w we go o furt ther r Our commitment to customer service and technical support extends to ofshore operations. With our robust global supply chain, we deliver the optimal marine lubrication solution to your ?eet, precisely when and where it’s needed.
1:33 PM Page 1 ANCHORS & CHAINS MILITARY SONAR SYSTEMS tel:+44 (0) 1752 723330, [email protected] , www.siliconsensing.com Anchor Marine & Supply, INC., 6545 Lindbergh Houston, Massa Products Corporation, 280 Lincoln Street, SONAR TRANSDUCERS Texas 77087 , tel:(713) 644-1183, fax:(713) 644-1185
MARKETPLACE Products & Services www.MaritimeEquipment.com Powering the fleet for 60 years! HYDRAULIC NOISE, SHOCK AND VIBRATION SUPPRESSOR Noise, Shock, VibraO on & PulsaO on in Quiet, Smooth Flow Out Oil Bladder Nitrogen (blue) Manufactured by MER
MARKETPLACE Professional www.MaritimeProfessional.com GILBERT ASSOCIATES, INC.GILBERT ASSOCIATES, INC. Naval Architects and Marine Engineers SHIP DESIGN & ENGINEERING SERVICES Join the industry’s #1 Linkedin group )NNOVATION
“The industry is an ecosystem which includes owners, managers, mariners, shipyards, equipment makers, designers, research institutes and class societies: all of them are crucial,” – Eero Lehtovaara, Head of Regulatory & Public Affairs, ABB Marine & Ports All images courtesy ABB Marine and Ports provi
Tech Files Latest Products, Systems and Ship Designs Zero-Emission Mooring Service of a Tanker Consulmar achieved a milestone by executing what it calls ing boat Castalia, which operates on full electric propulsion. the world's ? rst zero-emissions mooring service for a tanker. Equipped with two 150 kW
FEATURE INTERVIEW track missiles and warheads for the Mis- sile Defense Agency, and it travels with its support ship, the MV Hercules. For our Service Support ships, we have the two hospital ships, USNS Mer- cy and Comfort; two rescue and salvage ships; two submarine tenders; and the Sixth Fleet ?
RADM PHILIP SOBECK, MILITARY SEALIFT COMMAND With COVID, we had to make some hard choices for our Do your CIVMARs have upward mobility? mariners because we couldn’t rotate. Many of our mariners The Navy has Sailors who become “Mustangs,” and work found other employment, and were able to use their skills
RADM PHILIP SOBECK, MILITARY SEALIFT COMMAND Photo by Brian Suriani USN Military Sealift Command From a global supply chain perspective, What makes MSC so vital to the we’ve learned a lot about dealing with Navy’s ? eet and our military disruptions. COVID delivered a big forces around the world? wake-up
FEATURE INTERVIEW U.S. Navy photograph by Brian Suriani/Released Rear Adm. Philip Sobeck (right) Commander of U.S. Military Sealift Command (MSC) explains the tradition of the Navy ‘looping ceremony’. Lt. Robert P. Ellison assumes the title of MSC’s Flag Aide during the ceremony. NEEDS MILITARY MORE
INTERVIEW WE ARE ENGAGED WITH MULTIPLE US OSW WIND DEVELOPMENTS AND SEEING AN UP-TICK FOR CVA, TECHNOLOGY REVIEW AND RISK REDUCTION SERVICES IN EARLY DEVELOPMENT PHASES. WITH NEW LEASE ROUNDS COMING AND NEW OPPORTUNITIES, WE DO NOT SEE A BIG SLOWDOWN FOR OSW DEVELOPMENTS APART FROM THE OBVIOUS
ROB LANGFORD, VP, GLOBAL OFFSHORE WIND ob Langford has worked in the offshore industry ABS. “We are growing and evolving our services across all for more than three decades, ‘cutting his teeth’ offshore infrastructure along with our continued support to the in a UK design ? rm working in the North Sea
MARKETS SOVs – Analyzing Current, Future Demand Drivers By Philip Lewis, Director of Research, Intelatus © Björn Wylezich/AdobeStock t a high-level, there are three solutions to transferring Lower day rate CTVs are often used for daily transfer of technicians from shore bases to offshore wind farms
Editorial MARITIME REPORTER AND ENGINEERING NEWS his month’s coverage is M A R I N E L I N K . C O M almost an afterthought HQ 118 E. 25th St., 2nd Floor following the tragedy that New York, NY 10010 USA T +1.212.477.6700 Tunfolded in Baltimore in the wee hours of Tuesday, March 26, CEO John C.
Authors & Contributors MARITIME REPORTER AND ENGINEERING NEWS M A R I N E L I N K . C O M ISSN-0025-3448 USPS-016-750 No. 4 Vol. 86 Maritime Reporter/Engineering News (ISSN # 0025-3448) is published monthly Cooper Fischer Goldberg except for March, July, and October by Maritime Activity Reports, Inc.
Ahead Sanitation www.aheadsanitationsystems.com (337) 330-4407 29 All American Marine www.AllAmericanMarine.com (360) 647-7602 35 Bristol Harbor Group www.BristolHarborGroup.com (401) 253-4318 7 Caldwell Lifting Solutions www.caldwellinc.com (800) 628-4263 39 Creative Systems www.ghsport.com
& Companies Nevey to Head TAI Hires Kalla Washington State Ferries TAI Engineers appointed Amer Steve Nevey has been selected to Kalla as director of production design. serve as assistant secretary for the FMC Names Usman CIO Washington State Ferries Division, Nevey Schwandt succeeding Patty Rubstello
Vessels Gripper ing European CTV operator Northern Offshore Services (N-O-S) and U.S.-based investment ? rm OIC. The vessel, based on N-O-S’ 30-meter G-class design, fea- tures Volvo Penta’s IPS propulsion system and is said to be “hybrid-ready”, meaning it was built with space reserved for all the
Capt. Josh Ferguson, master of the eWolf. Administration (MARAD), which all provided ? nancial support and other resources. “This tug becomes somewhat commercially viable be- cause of the grant process,” Manzi said. “Unlike a ferry service that’s paid for by tax dollars, we have to collect fares and