Navy Repair And Overhaul Market
The Navy has clearly become the dominant source of ship repair, as well as new ship construction in the United' States. Ten years ago Navy business accounted for 36 percent of ship repair employment and 58 percent of new ship construction employment in U.S. shipyards. The figures are now 78 percent and 87 percent, respectively (see Exhibit 1).
In June 1983, IMA published a report on the Navy new construction market. A second report, on the Navy repair and overhaul market, is now being prepared.
Some information to be presented is highlighted in this article.
Future Business Opportunities The Navy has asked Congress for $2.8 billion in FY 1985 to fund 56 scheduled Navy ship overhauls.
This compares to $2.4 billion for 54 overhauls in FY 1984, and $2.5 billion for 59 overhauls in FY 1983.
Past policy has been to assign about 35 percent of this work to private shipyards. The remaining 65 percent of the work, especially overhaul of complex combatants, is performed in one of eight Navyowned shipyards.
Exhibits 2 and 3 list the scheduled overhauls of Navy and MSC ships over the next 12—24 months.
Forty-nine Navy and 28 MSC ship overhauls are scheduled. These jobs are to be awarded to commercial shipyards.
There are constraints on the competition: • Some have already been awarded as part of a multiship contract.
• To maintain crew morale, Navy's policy is to restrict competition on about one-third of overhauls to homeport shipyards. This policy doesn't affect MSC ships. But the ship relocation cost effectively limits Atlantic/Gulf shipyards to competing for Atlantic fleet MSC ships, and West Coast yards compete for Pacific fleet ships.
• NAVSEA and MSC are required to reserve some overhauls to competition among shipyards qualifying as small business firms. This particularly affects MSC overhauls as almost all are reserved for small businesses.
Equipment Sales Each overhaul requires replacement or addition of equipment. An example of the equipment variety and planned expenditure is provided in Exhibit 4. This shows equipment required for scheduled alterations planned for USS Simon Lake, a 20-year-old submarine tender.
Most long lead time equipment is directly purchased by Navy and provided to the shipyard as Government Furnished Equipment (GFE). More common equipment (e.g., refrigerators, hydraulic bench press, etc.) are typically included in the specification as items to be purchased by the shipyard as Contractor Supplied Equipment (CFE).
Our survey indicated a large percentage of mechanical, electrical and outfit equipment is purchased by the shipyard. Electronics equipment is purchased about evenly by Navy and contractor. Ordnance equipment is mostly purchased by Navy.
About 30-40 percent of the cost of a typical combatant overhaul will be subcontracted by the shipyard for material purchase. A large integrated yard le.g., Bath, Ingalls) will subcontract 2-5 percent for outside labor. Smaller yards may subcontract out 50 percent for specialized services.
Profitability of Navy Overhaul We asked master ship repair contractors about the profits in Navy overhaul work. Of 22 responses: • 9 respondents said Navy overhauls were less profitable than commercial repairs • 11 thought the Navy and commercial repair business had comparable profits • 2 said Navy was more profitable than commercial work Of the 49 Navy ship overhauls scheduled for the private sector over the next two years: • 31 will be fixed-price contracts • 14 will be cost-plus-award-fee contract • 4 will be cost-plus-fixed-fee contracts Fixed-price contracts squeeze profits from bidders in an industry hungry for work. U.S. ship repair yards are increasingly hungry for work! It is highly probable that Navy overhaul will be a low profit business over the next few years.
Technical Competitive Factors We asked master ship repair contractors to rank technical factors which affect award of Navy overhaul contracts. Exhibit 5 shows the response of 22 shipyards.
A peculiar pattern appears in these responses. Atlantic yards give high ranking to quality assurance, management experience in Navy work, in-place management, and previous performance on Navy contracts. Important factors to Pacific yards are political support in Congress, combat systems capability and drydocking capability.
Problems in Navy Overhaul Shipyards were also asked to rank problems in performing Navy overhaul work. Exhibit 6 shows the response.
All yards felt unrealistic bid pricing is the greatest problem.
Many said competition is cutthroat.
This reflects the state of shipyard business and reliance on a small number of big jobs from one customer.
Pacific coast yards seem to have particular problems receiving GFM/ GFI, but less difficulty getting decisions from the Navy.
Yard Improvements Planned We asked what type improvements each yard plans in overhaul and repair capabilities over the next several years. Exhibit 7 shows the response.
Over half the respondents said they are planning new drydocking facilities. A large number said they plan to improve machine shops and expand their engineering staff.
IMA's full report (about 200 pps.) on the Navy overhaul market will be available in May 1984. It will be sold for $480.
This price includes the initial report plus four quarterly updates.
The report can be obtained by writing: James R.
McCaul, President, International Maritime Associates, Inc., 1800 K Street, N.W., Washington, D.C.
A special pre-publication price of $380 is available to purchasers of the report who order prior to May 1.
Other stories from April 1984 issue
- Ames And O'Donnell Named Regional Directors For Maritime Administration page: 4
- Saint John Shipbuilding Upgrades Its CAD/CAM For Big Frigate Program page: 5
- C h e v r o n Selects Elinca System For 5 Ships — L i t e r a t u r e A v a i l a b le page: 5
- Transamerica Delaval Ends Its Technical Assistance Agreement With IMO AB page: 6
- Lykes Sign Letters O f Intent To Build Six C o n t a i n e r s h i ps page: 6
- B r o g a n A n d Sundaresan P r o m o t e d At MTL page: 6
- Bestobell Mobrey Promotes Houba And Bowerman To Sales Executive Posts page: 7
- Successful T r a n s p o r t Of Biggest-Ever D e c k Structure C o m p l e t e d By N e p t u n / NC page: 7
- N a v y Seeks Comments On I m p r o v i n g Pump Specifications page: 7
- Tokyo Marine Services Is Active Worldwide — Color Brochure Available page: 8
- Richard Faber Promoted To Marine/Military Sales Manager At Aeroquip page: 8
- N a v y Awards $822 M i l l i o n To Ingalls For Construction O f LHD-1 Assault Ship page: 8
- Washburn & Doughty Announces Signing Of Three Vessel Contracts page: 9
- N e w Division Formed At G e n e r a l Electric H e a d ed By W . J . C i m o n e t ti page: 9
- Board Approves Spin-off Of Sea-Land Service To Reynolds Shareholders page: 10
- Thomas Patterson Named President-General Manager Of Coastal Iron Works page: 10
- Desco M a r i n e Delivers Its First Boats Built O f Steel page: 10
- C y b e r n e t I n t r o d u c e s N ew V H F - F M R a d i o t e l e p h o ne — L i t e r a t u r e A v a i l a b le page: 10
- NKK Super Semi-Submersible Rig Designed For D e e p Sea O p e r a t i o ns page: 10
- St. Augustine Trawlers Delivers 600-Passenger Ferry For Mexico page: 11
- Joint S N A M E / C I M E M e e t i n g Discusses Heavy Lifts And Drydock O p e r a t i o ns page: 11
- Caterpillar Announces New Marine Diesel Engine Application Guidelines page: 12
- Transfer Vessel Coal M o n i t o r One Christened In N e w Orleans page: 12
- T a m p a S h i p y a r d s A w a r ds B a b c o c k & W i l c ox $ 1 . 4 - M i l l i o n C o n t r a ct page: 12
- Los Angeles S N A M E Meeting Discusses Floating Breakwater page: 12
- NKS Heavy Forging And Facility Nears Completion Casting In Mexico page: 13
- N e l s o n N a m e d President O f M . R o s e n b l a t t & Son page: 13
- Fishing Vessel C o n f e r e n ce T o Be H e l d M a y 1 0 - 1 2 In M e l b o u r n e , F l o r i da page: 13
- Product Planning Manager Named At American Standard/Heat Transfer page: 14
- First Vessel Enters N e w Floating Drydock At H a l i f a x Shipyard page: 14
- John H a s t i e S t e e r i n g G e ar P a r t s / S e r v i c e A v a i l a b le In U.S. F r om J e r e d Brown page: 14
- Bell Aerospace A w a r d e d $ 1 0 2 M i l l i on To Build Six M o r e LCACs For U.S. N a v y page: 14
- Kienitz And Flahaut Promoted At Pott's Inland Waterways Division page: 15
- A.P.I. TANKER CONFERENCE page: 16
- French Named Chairman And C EO At NASSCO—Vortmann Is President page: 18
- DoD Implements Initiative For Cost Effectiveness Of Contract Requirements page: 18
- N a v y A w a r d s E-Systems $ 4 . 7 - M i l l i o n C o n t r a ct page: 18
- I o w a M a r i n e Delivers Towboat Betty Edwards To M o r r i s H a r b o r Service page: 18
- MTL Announces Promotions page: 18
- M . A . N . - B & W Diesel Introduces N e w Engine page: 19
- S i g m a A w a r d e d M SC C o n t r a c t For 4 0 Bilge O i l y W a t e r S e p a r a t o rs page: 19
- Hampton Roads S N A M E Reports O n Ship Production Committee page: 19
- Incinerator Ship Apollo One Launched At Tacoma Boatbuilding page: 20
- M o r r i s G u r a l n i ck Elects R i c h a r d s on V i c e President page: 20
- W e l d e d B e a m A d ds C u s t o m T e e S h a p es T o P r o d u c t Line page: 21
- Marathon-Built Rowan Gorilla I Now Drilling Offshore Nova Scotia page: 22
- SURVIVAL AT SEA page: 22
- Bay-Houston Appoints Four Executives page: 24
- Alden Introduces New Whip Antenna For Radiofax — Literature Available page: 24
- Marine Travelift Introduces Another New Model In Its Boat Hoist Line page: 25
- Norwinch And MTT Unveil New Shipboard Crane — Literature Available page: 25
- Tanker Owners Federation Will Study Oil Spill Clean-Up For U.S. Navy page: 27
- TeleSystems Opens Maritime Sales Offices In New York And Los Angeles page: 28
- Amot Controls Introduces New Sensing Switches — Literature Available page: 28
- Sonat Exploration Names Executive Vice President page: 29
- Drew Ameroid Unveils New Fuel Additive — Literature Available page: 29
- Thornton Named President Of Martime Capital, Inc. page: 30
- Raymond International Expands Offshore Services To U.S. West Coast page: 30
- Airco Introduces New Pulsed Welding Systems — Literature Available page: 31
- C l o w / G r e e n b e r g O f f e rs B r o c h u r e O n Bronze V a l v e s A n d Fittings page: 31
- U n i r o y a l D e l t a Fender Systems P r o t e c t Pier A n d Ships A t N O R S H I P CO page: 31
- Wynholds Company Will Provide Computer Systems For Maersk Line Ships page: 32
- Parkway Adds Improved Features To Its Ocean Jacket Buoyancy System page: 32
- Three Navy Patrol Boats Delivered By Swiftships page: 32
- T r a i l e r M a r i n e T r a n s p o rt A w a r d e d $ 7 . 7 - M i l l i on M S C C o n t r a ct page: 33
- WABCO To Market New High-Torque Air Motor — Literature Available page: 34
- Hempel's Introduces New Antifoulings — Literature Available page: 34
- RORO84 Nice, Frace _ May 9 -11 page: 34
- Navy Repair And Overhaul Market page: 36
- Burness C o r l e t t / S e a w o r t hy O f f e r Unique R O / R O / T a n k e r Design page: 36
- S e m i n a r M a r k s O p e n i ng O f W a r t s i l a O f f i c e In V a n c o u v e r , B.C., C a n a da page: 36
- X a n t h o s N a m e d Sales M a n a g e r For Renk's B e a r i n g s D i v i s i on page: 37
- Puget S o u n d S e c t i o n / A S NE H e a r s P r e s e n t a t i o n O n E x p l o s i v e B o n d i ng page: 37
- Big 1 9 8 4 M R O C a t a l og N o w A v a i l a b l e F r om R e l i a n c e Electric page: 37
- K o c h - E l l i s C o m p l e t es N e w R O / R O F a c i l i ty — L i t e r a t u r e A v a i l a b le page: 37
- A S E A STAL A n n o u n c es C o r p o r a t e N a m e C h a n ge page: 37
- I M E M e e t i n g Discusses Use Of Epoxy Resins In Ship M &R page: 38
- B u l k f l e e t I n c o r p o r a t ed C o n s o l i d a t e s Under N e w N a me page: 38
- L a r i m e r N a m e d Chief E n g i n e e r i n g P l a n n i n g/ C o n t r o l M a r i n e t t e M a r i ne page: 38
- S N A M E S t a n d a r ds A n d S p e c i f i c a t i o n Panel To M e e t M a y 1 7 - 18 page: 38
- Ba l d t I n t r o d u c e s N ew W o r k b o a t C o n n e c t i n g Link — L i t e r a t u r e A v a i l a b le page: 39
- N e w York S N A M E Hears Paper On Computer-Based Preliminary Design page: 39
- Unique Lobster Boat Miss Julie D e l i v e r e d By G l a d d i n g - H e a rn page: 40
- o d d S e a t t l e To Refit T w o C o n t a i n e r s h i ps For Lykes Bros. page: 40
- John C r a n e O f f e rs F r e e Brochure On End F a c e Shaft Seals page: 40
- Furuno Unveils Low-Cost Color Video Plotter — Literature Available page: 42
- MarAd To Host Fleet Management Conference April 25-27 In Chicago page: 42
- a c k u p S a b i n e V A r r i v es A b o a r d D a n Lifter page: 42
- G e n s t a r Uses N o v e l T e c h n i q ue T o Launch P e t r o b r a s D r i l l i n g Rig page: 42
- Spring Meeting Of Great Lakes/Great Rivers SNAME Scheduled For May 17 page: 43
- Magnetrol Offers Brochure On Electronic Liquid Level Transmitters page: 43
- Sperry Awards Sanders $10-Million Contract page: 46
- T e x a s Instruments Unveils N e w Loran C N a v i g a t or — L i t e r a t u r e A v a i l a b le page: 46
- Lord M a r i n e Fenders A re M a n u f a c t u r e d In 2 2 Sizes — L i t e r a t u r e A v a i l a b le page: 46
- Joint SNAME/ASNE/MTS Meeting Hears Paper On Offshore Platforms page: 47
- ASNE Day '84 page: 48
- T r i m b l e N a v i g a t i o n I n t r o d u c es The M o d e l 3 0 0 L O R A N C o m p u t er — L i t e r a t u r e A v a i l a b le page: 51
- V a l m e t ' s N e w A u t o m a t i on System O r d e r e d For T wo Product C a r r i e r s At H y u n d ai page: 51
- Propellers '84 Scheduled For May 15-16 At Cavalier Hotel In Virginia Beach page: 64
- AWO A New Look At ADVOCACY AND INFLUENCE IN WASHINGTON page: 67
- Lingaas Named Senior VP For Cruise Operations At Holland America Line page: 69
- AIMS Endorses New Marine Firefighting Training Program page: 70
- Promotions Announced At Marine Transport Lines page: 70
- Worthington Offers New Cast Iron Pump Line — Literature Available page: 71
- Management Appointments Announced By Crowley's Caribbean Division page: 71
- OTC 84 page: 72
- Elinca Systems To Be Installed On Five Tankers Of Chevron Shipping Fleet page: 81
- Philadelphia Resins Offers New Bulletin On Its Wire Rope Socketing System page: 81
- New Lighting Systems Catalog Now Available From Rig-A-Lite Company page: 82
- FMC Introduces Two New Crawler Cranes And Heavy Lift Attachments page: 82
- NATIONAL MARITIME SHOW page: 84
- Free Bulletin Describes Complete Line Of Kohlenberg Airhorns page: 87
- McDermott Delivers Two Caterpillar-Powered Supply Vessels To Tidewater page: 88
- New Anti-Corrosion Paint Pigments Unveiled By BP page: 89
- Westinghouse Secures U.S. Patent On Self-Protecting Sensing Cell Electrodes — Literature Available page: 89
- Tuneable Hull Plate Reduces Propeller-Induced Noise/Vibration page: 93
- Tracor Marine Awarded $6-Million Contract To Convert AT&T Cable Ship page: 94
- Nationwide Boiler Awarded $1.8-Million Navy Contract To Upgrade Steam Plants page: 95
- Full-Color Worthington Brochure Covers Specs Of Redesigned Pumps page: 95
- MSC Awards Biospherics Contract For 40 Oilarms — Option For 40 More page: 96
- Meeting Of SNAME Great Lakes/ Great Rivers Section Discusses Fuel Additives And Hull Springing page: 98
- Drew Ameroid5 Marine Introduces Four Additions To Product Line page: 98
- Chugoku Introduces New Antifouling Hull Coatings — Literature Available page: 107